In 2003 and later some IASB members dissented from the issue of IAS 39 and subsequent amendments, and portions of their dissenting opinions relate to requirements that have been carried forward to IFRS 9. Those dissenting opinions are set out below.
Cross references that relate to the requirements that have been carried forward to IFRS 9 have been updated.
Dissent of Anthony T Cope, James J Leisenring and Warren J McGregor from the issue of IAS 39 in December 2003
DO1 Messrs Cope, Leisenring and McGregor dissent from the issue of this Standard.
DO2 Mr Leisenring dissents because he disagrees with the conclusions concerning derecognition, impairment of certain assets and the adoption of basis adjustment hedge accounting in certain circumstances.
DO3 The Standard requires in paragraphs 30 and 31 (now paragraphs 3.2.16 and 3.2.17 of IFRS 9) that to the extent of an entity’s continuing involvement in an asset, a liability should be recognised for the consideration received. Mr Leisenring
…