Are position management controls required to play a role in the application of position limits applied by NCAs according to Article 57(1) MiFID II?
Answer 1
No. NCAs are responsible for the application of position limits established under Article 57(1). Recital (128) MiFID further specifies that the powers to require the reduction or termination of a position or to provide back liquidity should "mitigate the effects of a large or dominant position".
However, the controls listed in Article 57(8) are not exhaustive and shall not prevent trading venues from developing their own position limits as a mean to control positions held on commodity derivatives traded on their trading venues.